Flexible Working Policies: A Practical Guide for Employers

Legal framework

Flexible working covers changes to working hours, working patterns or the place of work. Examples include part-time hours, compressed hours, flexitime, staggered hours, annualised hours, phased retirement and home or hybrid working. Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising ambitious businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including employment matters.

Employees in Great Britain have a statutory right to request flexible working from the first day of employment. They can make up to two statutory requests in a 12-month period. Employers must consult the employee before reaching a decision and normally respond within two months. The statutory procedure does not generally require an internal appeal. An employer can refuse a request only for one or more statutory business reasons, such as additional costs, difficulty reorganising work, an inability to recruit, or a detrimental effect on quality, performance or customer demand.

Building the policy

A written policy should explain the available working arrangements, eligibility for any company-specific scheme, the application process, decision-maker and timescales. If the organisation offers an internal appeal, the policy should explain the appeal route and how it operates. It should distinguish between a statutory flexible working request and an informal discussion about working arrangements. The policy should also state how the organisation will assess operational coverage, performance, supervision, customer service, confidentiality, equipment, health and safety, and information security.

Employers should assess each request on its facts rather than applying a blanket rule. They should record the reasons for approval or refusal and identify whether the arrangement is permanent, temporary or subject to review. An agreed change to contractual hours, days or workplace should be confirmed in writing. Records should include the request, consultation notes, decision and the resulting contract variation. Where the organisation has an internal appeal process, the records should also include the appeal and its outcome.

Equality and operational risks

Flexible working decisions should be checked against the Equality Act 2010. A refusal can create legal risk where it disadvantages an employee because of a protected characteristic. For example, working patterns connected with childcare can raise sex discrimination issues, while requests related to a disabled employee can overlap with the duty to make reasonable adjustments. Employers should consider whether a trial arrangement, altered hours or another adjustment addresses the underlying issue.

Managers should receive consistent guidance so that requests are not decided solely on personal preference or the requirements of a particular team. A practical assessment can cover the work that must be performed, the hours when it is needed, handovers, supervision, measurable outputs and the effect on colleagues. The organisation should review the arrangement after an agreed period and address performance or operational problems through the normal management process.

Suggested implementation process

An employer can adopt the following sequence:

  1. Publish a policy that reflects the statutory procedure and the organisation’s working arrangements.
  2. Train managers to acknowledge requests, consult properly and apply the same decision criteria.
  3. Assess the employee’s proposal against the statutory refusal grounds and relevant equality duties.
  4. Meet with the employee to discuss the practical effect of the arrangement and possible alternatives.
  5. Give a written decision within the required period, stating the reasons for any refusal.
  6. Record approved changes in the employment contract or a written variation.
  7. Review the arrangement using agreed measures, such as coverage, service levels, attendance and workload.

A policy is most effective when it sits alongside accurate employment contracts, a staff handbook and a clear process for handling grievances. If the organisation chooses to offer an appeal process, the policy should explain when an appeal is available and how it will be handled. Regular reviews should reflect changes in legislation, working practices and the organisation’s operational needs.