Flexible Working Decision Records: A Practical Guide

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on employment matters under the laws of England and Wales. A flexible working decision record provides a clear account of a request, the consultation process, the evidence considered and the final outcome.

What the record should cover

Employees have a statutory right to request flexible working from their first day of employment. A request must be made in writing and state that it is a statutory request, describe the proposed change, identify the date on which it should take effect, and list any previous statutory requests made during the preceding 12 months. The employer must deal with the request, including consultation, within two months unless a longer period is agreed. The record should capture the date received, the requested working pattern, the employee’s role, relevant contractual terms, meetings held and people involved in the decision.

Assessing the request

A decision record should separate facts from assumptions. It should explain how the proposed arrangement affects service coverage, workload, supervision, customer commitments, security, equipment and other operational requirements. The employer should record alternatives discussed, such as a different working pattern, a trial period or a revised start date. If the request is refused, the reason must fall within one of the eight statutory grounds, including additional costs, an effect on the ability to meet customer demand, an inability to reorganise work, an inability to recruit, or an adverse effect on quality or performance. The record should connect the selected ground to specific evidence.

Consultation, equality and contractual changes

The employer should record how it consulted with the employee and how it considered any practical adjustments. A flexible working decision must also be checked for discrimination risks. For example, a refusal that disadvantages an employee because of a protected characteristic requires careful assessment, particularly where the request relates to disability, childcare or religious observance. An approved arrangement can change contractual working hours, location or days. The decision record should state whether the change is permanent, temporary or subject to review, and identify any contract variation, payroll update, health and safety measure or data protection control required.

Keeping and using the record

A practical workflow is to acknowledge the request, check that it contains the required information, gather operational evidence, hold a consultation meeting, assess equality and contractual issues, record the decision and communicate it in writing. The employer should retain the request, meeting notes, evidence, decision and any agreed review date in accordance with its document retention policy, while limiting access to people with a genuine business need. The record supports consistent decision-making and provides an audit trail if the employee raises a grievance or brings a statutory claim. It should not replace the employer’s flexible working policy, staff handbook or employment contracts.