Harper James advises businesses on construction disputes under the laws of England and Wales, including disputes involving contracts, delay, defects, payment and professional negligence. Effective evidence usually determines whether a claim is resolved through negotiation, adjudication, mediation or court proceedings.
Start by identifying the contractual and factual issues. Check the signed construction contract, amendments, schedules, drawings, specifications, bills of quantities and relevant terms. Establish whether the project uses a JCT, NEC or another standard form, then record the clauses governing notices, extensions of time, variations, payment, defects and dispute resolution.
Prepare a chronology linking each event to the relevant contract provision. Include tender documents, site instructions, requests for information, design approvals, meeting minutes, progress reports, payment applications, assessment notices, programme updates, photographs and inspection records. Emails and messaging records should be preserved in their original form, with dates, recipients and attachments intact.
A delay claim requires evidence of the relevant event, its contractual effect, the period of delay and its effect on completion. Baseline and updated programmes, critical path analysis, site diaries, labour records, delivery records and weather data are commonly relevant. The evidence should distinguish delay caused by the employer, contractor, subcontractor or an external event.
Defect claims require the contract specification, inspection records, photographs, test results, snagging lists and independent technical assessments. A claim for money also needs evidence of causation and value, such as invoices, valuation records, remedial quotations, finance costs, prolongation costs and records of lost use or revenue. Unsupported estimates are less persuasive than calculations tied to project records.
Create a document index and separate factual evidence from legal analysis. Preserve relevant electronic data, including version histories and metadata, and avoid deleting or altering records after a dispute becomes foreseeable. Keep a record of who created each document and when. Witness statements should be based on personal knowledge, not assumptions or reconstructed accounts.
Obtain expert evidence where the dispute involves programming, valuation, structural condition, mechanical services or other specialist subjects. Experts should receive a balanced bundle of relevant material and understand the question they are asked to address. Early review of the evidence also identifies weak points, missing records and opportunities for mediation or settlement before substantial costs are incurred.