Harper James advises employers on employment dismissal procedures under the laws of England and Wales. A lawful dismissal requires both a potentially fair reason and a fair, reasonable process. The main potentially fair reasons are conduct, capability or performance, redundancy, statutory restriction, and some other substantial reason.
The employer should identify the issue clearly and collect relevant evidence before deciding on an outcome. For misconduct, this usually includes reviewing records, taking statements and holding an investigation meeting. For capability or performance concerns, the employer should set clear standards, provide reasonable support, allow time for improvement and consider medical evidence where relevant. Redundancy follows a separate process based on a genuine reduction in the need for employees to perform work, rather than the employee’s conduct or performance.
The employee should receive written details of the concerns and reasonable notice of a formal hearing. The invitation should explain the possible consequences, provide the relevant evidence and state the employee’s right to be accompanied by a trade union representative or workplace colleague. The Acas Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures is an important reference for misconduct and performance cases.
The person making the decision should consider the evidence objectively and allow the employee to respond. Possible outcomes include no action, a written warning, a final written warning, or dismissal. Gross misconduct can justify dismissal without notice, but the employer still needs to investigate and follow a fair procedure. The decision should be confirmed in writing, including the reason, termination date, notice arrangements, final pay, accrued holiday and the right of appeal.
An appeal should be handled by someone who was not responsible for the original decision where practicable. It should address procedural errors, new evidence and whether the outcome was reasonable. Employers should keep accurate records, including meeting notes, correspondence and the reasons for each decision.
Before dismissal, employers should check for risks involving discrimination, whistleblowing, trade union activities, health and safety, family-related leave and other automatically unfair reasons. Some claims do not depend on the employee having the usual qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal. The employer should also consider contractual notice, garden leave, post-termination restrictions, confidentiality and any settlement agreement. A settlement agreement is only binding when the statutory conditions are met, including independent advice for the employee.
Where the dismissal forms part of a redundancy exercise, the employer should consult affected employees, apply objective selection criteria and consider suitable alternative vacancies. Larger-scale redundancies may also require collective consultation and prescribed notifications. The procedure, evidence and written rationale should match the reason for dismissal, because a sound contractual entitlement to terminate does not by itself establish a fair dismissal.