Harper James advises businesses under the laws of England and Wales on commercial disputes, including debt recovery, mediation and litigation. A documented dispute process gives directors and management a consistent way to identify issues, preserve evidence, control legal spend and decide when formal action is justified.
The process should begin with a written dispute record. It should state the parties involved, the relevant contract or legal duty, the key events, the loss claimed and the outcome sought. Assign an internal owner and record important dates, including contractual notice periods, limitation deadlines, renewal dates and any dispute resolution procedure in the agreement.
An initial assessment should separate commercial disagreements from claims requiring urgent legal action. Review the contract, purchase orders, statements of work, correspondence, invoices and relevant policies. Check clauses covering governing law, jurisdiction, escalation, expert determination, mediation, arbitration, liability limits and legal costs. A senior manager should approve the proposed strategy and spending authority.
Businesses should issue a document preservation instruction as soon as a dispute is reasonably foreseeable. Relevant material includes emails, messaging records, meeting notes, call records, accounting documents, system data, photographs and contract versions. Employees should avoid deleting or altering records and should keep communications factual.
Many disputes begin with a structured internal review and a written letter before action. The letter should explain the legal and factual basis of the position, identify the remedy required, provide supporting documents where appropriate and set a reasonable response period. The parties can then consider negotiation or mediation. Mediation uses an independent mediator to help the parties reach a negotiated settlement, while leaving the decision with them.
If early resolution fails, the business should select the forum and procedure that fit the contract and the value, complexity and urgency of the claim. Options include a court claim, arbitration, adjudication for certain construction disputes, or a statutory demand for an undisputed debt. Court proceedings require compliance with the Civil Procedure Rules, including applicable pre-action protocols, statements of case, evidence and procedural deadlines.
A dispute budget should cover legal fees, expert evidence, court fees, counsel, disclosure, travel and potential liability for the other side’s costs. Management should receive regular reports on progress, exposure, settlement offers and decisions requiring approval. The business should also assess whether the dispute affects customers, suppliers, employees, insurers, lenders or regulatory obligations.
The process should end with a written settlement, judgment, award or closure decision. Record payment dates, confidentiality terms, releases, continuing obligations and enforcement steps. Afterward, review the cause of the dispute and update contract templates, approval procedures, service specifications, credit controls and staff training. A dispute register can track recurring issues, deadlines, financial exposure and lessons for future transactions.