Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including intellectual property disputes. A patent infringement claim usually alleges that a product, process or technical activity falls within one or more claims of a granted UK patent. The patent claims, rather than its title or general description, define the legal scope of protection.
First establish whether the communication is a solicitor’s letter, a formal claim issued in the High Court, or another form of procedure. Check the patent number, the alleged infringing acts, relevant dates, proposed remedy and response deadline. A letter before action is not the same as court proceedings, but ignoring it can lead to unnecessary cost and weaken the opportunity to resolve the dispute.
Stop routine deletion of relevant records and preserve product specifications, source code, laboratory notes, manufacturing documents, sales records, design changes and communications about the technology. Identify the people involved in design, testing, procurement and commercial decisions. The business should also record when the product was developed, launched and sold, and in which territories.
A technical and legal comparison is then made between the patent claims and the accused product or process. This normally requires claim construction, technical evidence and an assessment of whether each relevant element of a claim is present. The review should also examine ownership, patent status, renewal payments, territorial scope and whether the alleged acts fall within the patent term.
The response can challenge infringement, dispute the patent’s validity, or address both issues. Common validity grounds include lack of novelty, lack of inventive step, insufficiency and added matter. Depending on the circumstances, a defendant can seek revocation or raise invalidity as part of the proceedings. A non-binding UK Intellectual Property Office opinion can sometimes assist with an early assessment, but it does not determine the dispute.
Commercial options include changing the product or process, negotiating a licence, agreeing a settlement, or stopping the relevant activity. Any proposal should address continuing sales, stock, customer contracts, confidentiality, costs and the position of related companies. The business should not admit infringement, promise technical changes or disclose sensitive information before the patent and evidence have been reviewed.
If proceedings have been issued, the claim form and particulars of claim require prompt attention. The defendant must meet the applicable acknowledgement, defence and evidence deadlines, and should consider whether to bring a counterclaim for revocation or seek further information. Patent litigation is technically detailed and can involve expert evidence, disclosure, interim injunction applications and significant costs.
The immediate practical step is to assemble the patent, the claim correspondence and the relevant technical and commercial records, then prepare a structured response based on infringement, validity and business objectives. The appropriate strategy depends on the patent wording, the evidence, the stage of the dispute and the value of the affected product or market.