Thoughts and opinions

4 mins read

Updated on 28 October 2026

When AI gets it wrong: Could a mistake made by AI result in a business dispute? 

Our subject expert
Ian Carson

Partner and Head of Dispute Resolution

AI agents are moving further into the customer journey. They can answer questions, recommend products, process refunds and increasingly take actions on a customer’s behalf.

Recent reporting on AI shopping agents shows how quickly this is developing. Reuters reported that major banks were warning about risks including fraud, scams and data privacy as AI agents become more involved in online shopping.

For businesses, the issue isn’t simply whether an AI agent can make a mistake, but what happens when a customer relies on that mistake.

That raises an important commercial question: when an AI-generated mistake causes a customer to suffer a loss, who is responsible?

When a mistake by an AI agent becomes a business’s problem

The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has already addressed part of this question.

The government’s guidance on using AI agents says that businesses remain responsible for complying with consumer law when they use AI to deal with customers. The fact that a third party has supplied an AI agent doesn’t transfer that responsibility elsewhere.

The CMA gives the example of an AI agent that repeatedly gives customers the wrong information about a product’s features or their right to cancel. Businesses are expected to monitor how their AI agents perform and act quickly when they identify problems.

That could become particularly important where a customer relies on information an AI agent has provided and then acts on it.

An inaccurate answer doesn’t automatically mean there’s a legal claim. But if a customer relies on that information, enters into a transaction and subsequently suffers a loss, the mistake could become more than a customer service problem. It could become a dispute.

Then there is the AI provider

There may be another question behind the customer dispute. If the business didn’t build the AI agent itself, could it recover its losses from the provider? That will depend on the contractual relationship.

Businesses using third-party AI agents should consider what their agreements say about liability, indemnities, exclusions and limitations of liability. They should also understand:

These provisions may not receive much attention when everything is working as expected. They could become much more important when something goes wrong.

But there’s also an evidential issue. If a customer says an AI agent promised something, how does the business establish exactly what was said?

Was the interaction recorded? What information did the agent have at the time? Which version of the model was the customer using? Had the system or its instructions changed since the interaction?

Those questions could matter if the dispute develops into a legal claim.

None of this means your business should avoid using AI. The CMA recognises the potential benefits of AI agents, while emphasising the importance of testing, monitoring and human oversight.

For businesses, the practical question is whether you’re considering those protections alongside the commercial and contractual risks.

Before you allow an AI agent to interact directly with your customers, you should consider the following:

The business case for AI is increasingly clear. The more difficult question is what happens when the technology fails.

An AI agent can make a mistake in seconds, but resolving the consequences may take considerably longer.

As AI takes a greater role in customer relationships and transactions, you should not only ask what the technology can do for you, but what happens when a customer relies on it, something goes wrong and the relationship turns into a dispute.

The AI may have delivered the answer. But if that answer causes a dispute, your business may still be the one left dealing with the consequences.

Ian Carson, Head of Dispute Resolution at Harper James, comments:

Businesses shouldn’t assume that an AI-generated statement sits outside the legal relationship with their customer. If a customer has relied on information provided by an AI agent acting on the business’s behalf, the circumstances of that interaction could become highly relevant if a dispute arises. Businesses need to understand what their AI agent is authorised to say and do, and what protections are in place when it gets something wrong.

Thoughts and opinions

13 October 2026

What the latest cyber incidents tell SMEs about third-party risk 

Thoughts and opinions

21 September 2026

When a bigger brand challenges your trade mark: lessons from Airbnb and bnb-side 

Thoughts and opinions

10 September 2026

Corporate reporting reform: what could it mean for growing businesses?

Thoughts and opinions

21 August 2026

The Anthropic settlement and the risks of a “use first, pay later” approach to AI and...

Thoughts and opinions

31 July 2026

How can we help?

To access legal support from just £174 per hour arrange your no-obligation consultation today. We aim to respond to all messages received within 24 hours.

Make an enquiry