Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising ambitious businesses on intellectual property disputes and the laws of England and Wales. Its guidance on patent disputes sits alongside the practical work of defining the issues, documents and information relevant to a potential claim. An evidence file should identify the patent, the suspected infringing product or process, the relevant parties, and the dates on which the conduct occurred.
Start by obtaining the complete patent specification, granted claims, publication details and current register information. Confirm the patent’s owner, any recorded assignments or licences, and whether it is in force for the relevant period. In the UK, infringement is assessed against the patent claims, rather than against the general subject matter described in the specification.
A claim chart compares each element of an asserted patent claim with the corresponding feature of the accused product or process. Use separate rows for the elements of each independent claim, then address any additional limitations in dependent claims. Record the source of every factual assertion, such as product manuals, technical drawings, user instructions, public demonstrations, regulatory filings, photographs, test results or admissions.
The comparison should distinguish between directly observed features and conclusions that require technical analysis. Record product versions, model numbers, software releases and inspection dates, since later changes can affect the relevance of the evidence. If the alleged infringement concerns a process, document the steps performed and the evidence showing that those steps occur.
Keep original files in their original formats and maintain a record of when, where and how each item was obtained. Preserve web pages, emails, sales materials and online videos with their surrounding context, including URLs and access dates. Do not alter originals through editing or annotation. Store working copies separately and use consistent file names and an index.
Witness statements should explain the witness’s role, knowledge and method of observation. Technical evidence may require an independent expert, particularly where infringement depends on engineering, software or scientific issues that are not apparent from public materials. Legal advice and litigation documents also require careful handling because privilege and disclosure rules apply differently to different categories of material.
Before issuing a claim, separate the infringement analysis from questions about patent validity, ownership, jurisdiction, limitation periods and available remedies. A strong technical match does not by itself resolve whether the patent is valid or whether the proposed defendant is the correct party. The evidence file should therefore include a chronology, a list of potential witnesses, a schedule of missing documents, and an assessment of evidential gaps.
The file should support a clear decision about the next step, such as seeking further information, sending correspondence, pursuing settlement discussions or preparing proceedings. It should also identify the commercial importance of the dispute, including the products affected, likely costs, business relationships and the need to preserve evidence as the matter develops.