Knowledge Hub
for Growth


How employers can avoid redundancy claims


Article

8 mins read

Updated on 1 April 2025

Our subject expert
Simon Gilmour

Partner and Head of Employment Law

Handling redundancies is one of the toughest challenges for any employer, and getting it wrong can lead to costly legal claims, damage to your reputation, and damage team morale. Understanding your legal obligations and following a fair, well-structured process is essential to reducing risk and protecting your business.

In this article, you’ll learn the key steps to avoid redundancy claims, from proper consultation and selection processes to offering suitable alternatives and handling appeals. And if you need expert legal support, our employment law solicitors are here to help you manage redundancies confidently, fairly, and with minimal risk.

Contents:

  1. The key steps of a fair redundancy process
  2. What are some of the most common pitfalls?
    1. Calling it redundancy when it isn’t
    2. Getting the selection pool wrong
    3. Using subjective selection criteria
    4. Late or insufficient consultation
    5. Failing to consider alternative roles
    6. Forgetting that special rules apply to employees who are pregnant or new parents
  3. What are the common legal claims an employee can bring?
  4. Using an employment lawyer to support you through the process and reduce risk
  5. What to do if an employee brings a claim
  6. Summary

A recent survey of 2,000 employers carried out by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) revealed that redundancy intentions are at their highest level in 10 years, barring the Covid pandemic with just over a third of the 2,000 firms it spoke to saying they planned to reduce their headcount through redundancies or by recruiting fewer workers. There are key steps in the redundancy process that will help you avoid redundancy claims. Our employment law experts guide you through the process, as even the most diligent employer can get caught out by redundancy pitfalls.

Increases to employer National Insurance Contributions and National Minimum Wage rates from April 2025, together with rising costs, have created a challenging time for many businesses, leading to difficult decisions concerning their staff.  Unfortunately, for some businesses, redundancy may be the only option, but a redundancy process is not straightforward. The consequences of getting it wrong can be both financially costly if it leads to legal claims but also risk reputational damages and a demoralised workforce. 

The key steps of a fair redundancy process

  1. Consider alternatives - redundancies should be a last resort and so it’s important to explore alternatives at an early stage with your employees. This could include reducing pay, temporary layoffs or voluntary redundancies. 
  2. Inform employees and identify the pool of employees at risk of redundancy and score them fairly against objective criteria.
  3. Consider whether any employees are pregnant, on or have recently returned from family leave as different redundancy protection rules apply
  4. Arrange meetings with employees to engage in genuine and meaningful consultation
  5. Consider whether there are any suitable alternative roles available
  6. Give notice of termination of employment and make statutory redundancy payment if applicable
  7. Offer a right to appeal

What are some of the most common pitfalls?

Calling it redundancy when it isn’t

Redundancy has a specific legal meaning so to fairly dismiss on the grounds of redundancy, you will need to ensure that any planned changes fall within the legal definition of redundancy.  A redundancy situation can arise when you:

Not every organisational change will amount to a redundancy – for example redistributing work among the same number of employees or changes to terms and conditions such as working hours may not meet the definition of redundancy.

It’s also important to ensure that the redundancy is not a sham to hide another reason for dismissal such as performance or misconduct.

Getting the selection pool wrong

Selection pools help make sure employees are selected for redundancy in a fair way.  It will be important to consider which kind of work is disappearing and which employees do this work.

You should include all roles that are the same or similar in each pool and also consider including roles that have similar skills.

For example, if you need fewer employees to carry out marketing roles you may consider including PR roles in the selection pool as well if the skills are broadly similar to those needed for marketing.

Choosing an appropriate pool can be one of the most difficult issues to get right. A wider pool is likely to have a more detrimental impact on morale and require more time from management and HR in terms of overseeing the process. But if the pool is too narrowly defined employees who are subsequently selected for redundancy may argue they wouldn’t have been selected if others were included in the pool.

Using subjective selection criteria

Any selection criteria used must be objective where possible to avoid personal opinions being taken into account. Unless there are selection criteriapre-determined in your redundancy policy or agreed with Trade Unions or employee representatives, there is some flexibility in the selection criteria you can choose to score employees in the pool for selection.

Some objective criteria which are easily measurable might include:

Using the criteria Last In First Out (LIFO) is OK in principle if considered alongside other objective criteria, but it should not be used alone as a means of selection as this could potentially be age-discriminatory.

It is important that discrimination does not creep into the process of scoring against the selection criteria. For example, if using attendance is a criteria, you should disregard absences relating to disability, pregnancy, maternity or other family leave. 

Late or insufficient consultation

You should consult with your employees at an early stage about why the proposed redundancies are necessary, ways to avoid or reduce the number of redundancies and any selection criteria to be used in the scoring process.   It’s important that consultation is meaningful and not just a box-ticking exercise as this could lead to a finding that the decision to make an individual redundant or a group of employees redundant was a forgone conclusion.

Failing to consider alternative roles

An employee who is selected for redundancy should be offered any available vacancy that would be suitable, even if it is at a lower salary or at a lower status than the post from which they are being made redundant, and you should continue to consider any other roles that become available until the end of any notice period being worked.

If an alternative role is offered on different terms, there is a statutory four-week trial period for both the employer and the employee to decide whether the alternative employment is suitable.

Forgetting that special rules apply to employees who are pregnant or new parents

Employees who are pregnant or new parents have special protection in a redundancy situation which means that if they are selected for redundancy, they must be offered a suitable alternative vacancy if there is one available in your organisation in priority to other employees at risk of redundancy.

This redundancy protection during pregnancy and maternity starts when an employee informs you they are pregnant, and ends 18 months from the exact date the baby is born.  This special protection also applies to employees who are taking shared parental leave, adoption leave or from April 2025, neonatal care leave. 

What are the common legal claims an employee can bring?

The key claims that can arise when a redundancy process goes wrong are: 

Using an employment lawyer to support you through the process and reduce risk

Embarking on a complex redundancy process can be daunting and with so much at stake, you may decide that it is worth taking legal advice at the outset to ensure that what you are planning is legally compliant and to guide you through the process to minimise the risks of legal claims which can be financially costly as well as potentially damaging to your reputation.  Employment Tribunal judgements are published online which could of course impact your reputation and standing with remaining employees and possibly with customers.

What to do if an employee brings a claim

You will usually be notified if an employee is considering making a claim as the employee must first raise a complaint by ACAS, which is known as the early conciliation process.  It's important to engage in the process as this will give you an understanding of what issues the employee is looking to raise and what resolution they are looking for (usually compensation). 

We would recommend consulting a solicitor at this stage to advise on the prospects of successfully defending a claim by the employee and whether it would be in your interests to consider reaching an early settlement.

Summary

Navigating a redundancy process can be challenging for any business, so careful planning and management of the process is key to avoid mistakes.  Consulting our employment law solicitors at an early stage can ensure that you avoid the common pitfalls and reach the best outcomes for all involved.

About our expert

Simon Gilmour

Partner and Head of Employment Law

Simon is a highly experienced employment lawyer who has been advising businesses on employment and HR matters since qualifying in 1994. As Head of Employment at Harper James, he works closely with businesses to solve complex people-related issues. Simon has spent more than 30 years advising businesses on complex workplace issues, including 18 years as a partner and Head of Department.

View Profile 


Areas of Expertise

Absence & Sickness Management Business Immigration Compliance Audit Business Immigration Law Dealing With Discrimination For Employers Defending Employment Tribunal claims Discipline & Grievance Procedures Employment Contracts and 9 more...

Recent content

24 July

Employment Rights Act: the Fair Work Agency (FWA)... 

14 July

Employment Rights Bill: Government response to Bus... 

14 April

Responsible redundancy: Establishing genuine redun... 

24 March

Redundancy notice periods... 

10 March

Extended redundancy protection for employees on ma... 