Knowledge Hub
for Growth


Break clauses in commercial property leases


Article

12 mins read

Updated on 14 June 2024

Our subject expert
Abdi Ebrahimi

Partner - Commercial Property Development

Break clauses are a vital tool in commercial leases, giving both landlords and tenants the flexibility to end an agreement early if business needs or circumstances change. However, recent Supreme Court decisions have clarified just how strictly these clauses must be followed, making it more important than ever to get the details right.

In this guide, you’ll learn what a break clause is, how the latest legal judgments affect your rights, and the practical steps needed to exercise a break clause successfully. By understanding the risks and requirements, you can avoid costly mistakes and protect your business interests.

If you need tailored advice on break clauses or support with serving notice, our commercial property solicitors are here to help, get in touch for clear, business-focused guidance.

Here we’ll be covering:

  1. What is a break clause?
  2. Negotiating a break clause
  3. Examples of pre-conditions often attached to break clauses
  4. The relationship between a break clause and other provisions of a lease
  5. Break clauses and payment requirements
  6. When and how to give notice for a break clause
  7. What about joint tenants?
  8. Can you withdraw a break notice once it has been served?
  9. What are the potential costs associated with exercising a break clause?
  10. What happens if a tenant fails to vacate the property after activating a break clause?
  11. Summary

What is a break clause?

A break clause can be included in a fixed-term commercial lease allowing either the tenant or landlord to bring the lease to an end early. The terms of the break clause and who can exercise it will depend on negotiations at the Heads of Terms stage. Sometimes the break clause is personal to the original landlord or the original tenant or both.

Depending on how the lease has been drafted, the right to break the lease may:

A break clause may only be exercised if any conditions attached to it have been satisfied.

Negotiating a break clause

Negotiating the wording of a break clause is best done by an experienced legal professional who can guide you as to the pitfalls and implications of the terms proposed by the other party and aim to protect your interests/position. Often it is a case of striking a balance between allowing flexibility for the tenant while assuring the landlord that he or she will not be left at a disadvantage by breaking the lease. Here are a few areas to bear in mind when it comes to negotiations:

Examples of pre-conditions often attached to break clauses

Some examples of pre-conditions often attached to break clauses are as follows:

The break clause should specify whether the conditions must be satisfied at the date the break notice is served, or at the specified break date, or both. If any pre-conditions are not strictly complied with, the right to break may be lost.

The relationship between a break clause and other provisions of a lease

Break dates are often linked to rent review dates so that, if the tenant considers a rent increase to be too great, they can end a commercial lease early.

If a headlease is terminated by the exercise of a break clause of either party, then any underlease also ends. This applies even where the underlease was granted with the consent of the head landlord. If Part II of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 applies to the underlease so that it is a protected tenancy, a statutory tenancy for the undertenant will arise on the termination of the underlease.

There may be general obligations that apply at the end of the term of the lease, which will need to be complied with before the break date. For example, the lease may require the tenant to remove signage, reinstate alterations and redecorate the property. Reviews of any supplemental documents should also be made, such as any licences granted for works to the property in case these contain obligations that are relevant to the break.

A tenant may ask the landlord for confirmation of the steps required to comply with any conditions in the break clause. As a tenant, you will want to ensure that you have complied with your repairing obligations under the lease. To do this, you may ask the landlord to prepare a list of items that are in need of repair and for which you are responsible under the lease. This list is known as a schedule of dilapidations.

If a tenant agrees to carry out works to the property before the break date, be careful to ensure that the works are completed, and vacant possession is given by the break date.

A tenant will also want to ensure that any waiver of a break clause condition by the landlord is not made ‘without prejudice’ and it is clear to which condition(s) the waiver applies.

Break clauses and payment requirements

Considerations on payments connected to break clauses should include the following:

When and how to give notice for a break clause

As a tenant, you will want to consider carrying out a compliance audit with a surveyor’s advice before serving the break notice. You can then take steps to remedy any breaches of the lease. This is particularly important where such compliance is a condition of the break clause.

You should serve the break notice in good time and strictly follow the terms of the lease. The lease may contain provisions relating to serving the break notice that is not in the break clause itself.

Keep evidence of the method of posting or delivery of the notice. If there are no provisions in the lease that relate to serving the break notice, the party serving the notice could request that the receiving party acknowledge receipt, although the receiving party is not obliged to comply with that request.

If the notice is being served by an agent, make sure the receiving party is aware of the existence of the agency arrangement and the agent’s authority.

What about joint tenants?

Only a person with the benefit of a break clause can exercise the clause. In the case of joint tenants, this typically means that the right to break must be exercised by both (or all) parties unless there is a specific provision in the lease that this is not the case/explicit authority that one party can exercise the break clause on behalf of others.

Can you withdraw a break notice once it has been served?

Unless the lease states otherwise a break notice cannot be withdrawn unilaterally. A party seeking to terminate must be certain that they wish to bring the lease to an end. If a tenant has served a break notice and changes their mind, the landlord may agree to its withdrawal, but this is entirely up to the landlord.

Even if the landlord and the tenant both agree to waive the break notice, this does not prevent the lease from ending. Instead, the landlord will have to grant a new lease that will take effect immediately after the original lease ends under the break clause.

What are the potential costs associated with exercising a break clause?

What happens if a tenant fails to vacate the property after activating a break clause?

Once a tenant has exercised a break clause validly, they must vacate the premises and return the property (and keys) to the landlord on the break date as per the terms of the lease. Unless the landlord agrees otherwise, failure to vacate the property after activating a break clause technically puts the tenant in breach and they can be treated as a trespasser. It is open to the landlord to initiate legal proceedings to enforce the break clause and regain possession of the property. This could result in additional time and expenses for both parties.

The tenant may also be liable for rent payments and other obligations under the lease agreement until they vacate the property, even after activating the break clause. The landlord may pursue legal action to recover any outstanding rent, incurred costs or damage resulting from the tenant's failure to vacate, such as loss of rental income or legal fees.

Summary

Break clauses provide a useful and flexible mechanism for business tenants to exit a lease depending on their commercial situation. It is important to make sure that the mechanics and wording of the break clause are clear, as any ambiguity can lead to costly mistakes or disputes further down the line.

As a business owner or commercial tenant, ending a lease isn’t always straightforward. Whether you're navigating a break clause, dealing with dilapidations or exploring early termination options, the risks and costs can quickly escalate without the right advice. Our commercial property solicitors support businesses across the UK by reviewing leases, advising on exit routes and negotiating favourable outcomes.

About our expert

Abdi Ebrahimi

Partner - Commercial Property Development

Abdi is a partner in Harper James' commercial property team. He advises clients on general commercial property matters with a particular interest and specialism in relation to development work. This includes reviewing and advising on heads of terms, carrying out title investigations, reviewing and reporting on the benefit or burden of rights and helping clients to understand and manage the risks associated with the land being bought or sold. Once a site has been acquired, Abdi supports clients with the various section agreement and ancillary documents needed to facilitate the development of the land through to the eventual sale or desired exit strategy. 

View Profile 


Areas of Expertise

Commercial Lease Agreement Review Commercial Lease Solicitors Commercial Property Conveyancing Commercial Property Disputes Commercial Property Solicitors Property Development Solicitors Property Finance Solicitors and 2 more...

Recent content

27 August

GC Focus: Commercial property priorities... 

26 March

Understanding conditional contracts and option agr... 

4 February

Unlocking development potential – identifying th... 

7 January

How to avoid overpaying or misjudging site value: ... 

6 November

What is a Section 106 agreement?... 