Article
11 mins read
Updated on 3 October 2019
Our subject expert
Jas Bhogal
Partner - Corporate
Shareholder activism is on the rise, and it’s something no business can afford to ignore. Whether driven by financial motives, governance concerns, or broader strategic aims, activist shareholders are increasingly using their rights to influence how companies are run.
This guide is for company directors, in-house counsel, and shareholders who want to understand what shareholder activism is, how it can affect your business, and how to prepare and respond effectively. You’ll learn about the legal tools available to shareholders, common tactics, and how to safeguard your company’s leadership and strategy.
If your business is facing shareholder pressure or you're concerned about governance risks, our corporate lawyers can help you take a proactive approach.
Shareholder activism involves extreme actions taken or proposed by shareholders of a company to further their agenda. This agenda is usually at odds with the motivations and strategy of the company and its directors. This action can result in disputes or conflicts with a company’s management. Shareholder activism takes a number of different forms, including shareholders using their legal rights, public pressure and information gathering.
Shareholder activism is important because even though on the one hand it can be seen as a block to the efficient running of a company, it is a movement that demonstrates that the owners of a company can have a key role in shaping operational decision-making. It also reminds directors that the shareholders of the company are watching what they are doing and how they are doing it, so it is important for directors to make sure that they are promoting good corporate governance and are meeting all of the company’s compliance requirements, particularly in areas such as anti-bribery and anti-corruption. In the long term, shareholder activism can influence or change the way companies are run, so it’s important to be aware of the trend and the direction in which it is moving.
Shareholder activism in the United Kingdom can take a number of forms, and will depend on whether the company is a private or public company and the status of its shares. Shareholder activism can take the form of:
All of these types of shareholder actions are likely to have some effect on the operations of a company and will cause various levels of disruption and speculation. In turn, that commotion will require the company to spend time and administrative resources that could otherwise be used to run the company.
On one side of the scale, public announcements will not necessarily be particularly financially burdensome to the company. On the other side of the scale, statutory actions such as unfair prejudice petitions or derivative claims, if successful, could result in a fundamental change forced upon a company by court order, dictating how it should be run. These statutory claims can also be costly, particularly if the court decides that the company is to bear the costs of the proceedings.
Shareholder activism can be both good and bad – your opinion will largely depend on who you are.
In general, shareholder activism is good for shareholders (and other stakeholders in a company) that want to make sure that the company is being run in a way that they agree with. However, this assumes the shareholders that are raising the grievances are acting in a way that is reasonable and for the good of the shareholders as a whole.
On the other side, the company is unlikely to think that shareholder activism is a good thing, particularly when it interrupts the running of the company or circumnavigates the normal processes in place for the company to address shareholder concerns. Again, this assumes that the directors of a company are acting in its best interests rather than trying to avoid scrutiny in order to follow their own agenda.
| Benefits | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Increases efficiencies and may make more money for the company – if seasoned investors are more involved with the decision making, the more likely that their experience will positively influence the strategy of the company | Likely to cause disruption to the running of the company |
| Increases the need for the board of directors to be self-reflective and assess how they are running the company | Likely to cause expense to the company |
| May result in changes to governance and other internal compliance policies that mean that the company is more transparent and accountable | May result in market speculation of the company resulting in reputational damage or even a lower share price |
| Gives potential investors more information about the company | May undermine the power of the directors to manage the company |
Traditionally, most disputes between shareholders and directors in businesses in the UK would be handled in a private forum – it has only been in the last decade or so that shareholder activism in the UK has increased, with more investors of different types starting to try to actively influence how the company that they are investing in is run, and how and to what extent it turns a profit.
Recent examples of such shareholder activism in the UK have happened as recently as January 2019, when Whitbread plc sold its Costa Coffee business to The Coca-Cola Company after pressure from its fund shareholders to break up its business. Also, in February 2019, following discussions with its largest shareholders, the board of directors of Premier Foods plc decided to conduct a review of its strategic options for increasing shareholder value.
How do you know if your shareholders are preparing for activist behaviour? Often you can get an indication of unrest or a brewing dispute by communicating with the shareholders as a group at a general meeting or directly on an informal basis.
It may even become apparent by tracking company-related social media sites and pages. An unhappy shareholder will often be vocal in general meetings and an activist shareholder will almost certainly be. In a public company, under statutory law the board can be required to answer all questions posed by shareholders that relate to the company’s business.
Ultimately, the best preparation is preventative action – as a director, you want to maintain an open channel of communication with the company’s shareholders to make sure that shareholders feel they have some influence over the company’s strategy and a forum to voice any concerns they may have. Being transparent in your actions as a director and explaining the rationale behind decisions can take you far in keeping shareholder activism at bay, particularly if the company has recently engaged in unusual trading activity or more heavy duty borrowing.
In responding to shareholder activism, it is helpful for directors to view themselves as custodians of the company for its owners (the shareholders) and position themselves accordingly. If a director were to find themselves in the middle of an activist event, they would need to try and take the position that their role is to facilitate the progress of the company and to approach the shareholders in a conciliatory and helpful way rather than to instigate a dispute or any further bad will at this stage.
The key is to make it clear to the shareholders (and if necessary, the public) why the directors decided to act or not act in a certain way and to back up this announcement with as much justifiable evidence as is available.
Where shareholders have forced the convening of a general meeting or have proposed a resolution to be considered at a general meeting (or an annual general meeting if the company is a public company), it is for the directors to present a clear and well-reasoned case as to why the decisions proposed are not reasonable or suitable for the company to pass.
This may involve enlisting the assistance of the company’s auditors or financial advisers to support the directors’ argument. The directors should make sure that the meeting is convened and run in accordance with the statutory rules set out in the Companies Act 2006 and the company’s articles of association (the company’s rule book). This can also be a good way of eliminating any shareholders who are not technically entitled to vote at or attend the meeting from doing so.
How the directors respond to an activist event can have an impact on the company’s reputation and the perceived trustworthiness of the board. It is better if the board can demonstrate to the shareholders that they have a desire to understand the causes for concern that the shareholders have voiced. At the same time, the company will want to make it known publicly that it’s response is reasonable and proportionate. This can be disseminated through news stories, social media platforms and other publicity.
Shareholder activism in the UK has been in and out of the news over the last decade or so, as it’s been on the rise ever since the financial crisis hit around 2007. At a time when people were increasingly uncertain about the nature of their investments, there was a call to take a closer look at how companies (public or listed companies in particular) were being run and to investigate suspicious actions.
The public were keen to criticize ‘big companies’ and this distrust filtered through the UK market affecting both public and private companies. HSBC, Vodafone, Tesco and Cadbury Schweppes all made the news as a result of shareholder activism, where shareholders were campaigning against a variety of topics that affected how the companies were being operated and the decision-making process behind company strategy.
The trends that have become apparent show a shift towards shareholders increasingly becoming interested in influencing, directly or indirectly, the financial and strategic agenda. Shareholders are looking at the transactions that a company is involved in and the revenue and profit that such transactions generate. They can do this by buying enough of a shareholding to put pressure on the board, to veto or push through decisions that will fundamentally affect the company (and often increase the share price of the company), such as the buying and selling of shares or the sale of the company’s assets.
There are a number of legal and regulatory tools available to shareholders to facilitate activism. They include:
About our expert
Partner - Corporate
Jas is a corporate partner who helps start-ups, high-growth businesses and investors navigate fundraising, investment and the corporate issues that arise as businesses scale.
Corporate Governance Lawyers Corporate Law Corporate Restructuring Crowdfunding Legal Services Debt Finance Exits and Disposals Funding Round Legal Advice and 12 more...
25 April
Negotiating your term sheet and deal terms: top ne...
24 April
Red flags in term sheets: what founders must know...
31 March
EIS schemes: how to apply and attract funding...
31 March
Enterprise Investment Schemes (EIS): is it the rig...
28 February