Article
8 mins read
Updated on 26 July 2024
Our subject expert
Matthew Shakesheff
Partner - Corporate
Earn-outs are a popular way to bridge the gap between a buyer’s and seller’s valuation, but they can be a legal and commercial minefield if not handled with care. While an earn-out allows sellers to receive part of the purchase price based on future performance, poorly structured agreements can lead to disputes, misaligned incentives, and frustrated expectations.
In this guide, we explore how earn-out disputes arise, the key clauses to include in your sale and purchase agreement, and practical steps both parties can take to reduce risk and maximise the chance of a smooth transaction.
Our M&A lawyers have advised founders, sellers and buyers on hundreds of earn-out structures in M&A deals, from start-up exits to complex corporate acquisitions. Whether you’re negotiating heads of terms or reviewing a draft SPA, we’ll help you protect your interests and avoid costly disputes
Here are some reasons why earn-out disputes arise:
Unfortunately, earn-out disputes are common. The best way to protect yourself, whether you’re a buyer or a seller, is to make sure you follow these rules:
Here are some key points to consider when structuring an earn-out:
The earn-out clause should at a minimum include:
For more information, see our article How to structure and negotiate an earn-out.
An earn-out amount can be a set sum payable on achievement of the relevant target, or a series of variable amounts. The earn-out amount may be a percentage of profits or a multiple of that amount, and these sums could be capped or subject to a minimum. The earn-out sum may be payable in cash, or in some other way, such as shares.
When debating earn-out targets, think about how to tackle variations in performance.
Will the buyer accelerate an earn-out payment if the seller breaches a covenant in the sale purchase agreement, or sells the company, or it becomes insolvent?
It can be difficult to measure performance accurately, particularly if a company has been merged into the buyer’s business. Sellers should insist that the buyer keeps separate books and records for the target. You could also agree to calculate performance on a consolidated basis, allocating a specific percentage to the target company’s operations.
You may be able to delay the start of the earn-out period so that the target can ‘bed-in’ to new management and absorb any exceptional costs relating to the acquisition.
Make sure that you’ve allowed enough time to prepare the earn-out calculations, and make sure your staff and advisors are available.
Buyers should avoid long earn-out periods as this may give an unrealistic picture of the target’s underlying merit. They should also avoid a too-short period so that the target has time to absorb the acquisition costs.
These clauses can also be helpful:
When calculating the earn-out amount, the post-sale period is critical. Both the buyer and the seller should protect themselves against the company’s performance being artificially manipulated.
The seller needs to make sure that the buyer manages the company in such a way that the risk of not meeting KPIs is minimised. For example, a seller may insist that the buyer doesn’t make material changes to the way the business is run, or veto certain decisions during the earn-out period, such as firing key staff or taking on too much debt. They might also insist that the buyer dedicates a sufficient budget to marketing and sales activity post-completion.
If the seller stays on post-sale, the buyer should ensure they manage the business effectively during the earn-out period. They should also consider what will happen if the seller decides to leave before the end of the period.
You can also include an earn-out when an acquisition is structured as an asset purchase rather than a share sale, and apply the same reasoning when structuring the earn-out.
The issues we’ve described in this guide apply equally when negotiating a term sheet. Be clear about your expectations, and make sure the document accurately reflects these.
In summary:
The buyer is usually in the driving seat when it comes to earn-outs. The usual reason for an earn-out is to bridge the gap between the seller and the buyer’s valuations. A buyer can also limit their risk by requiring the seller to stay on for a period to maximise value to the buyer.
There are several problems with earn-outs. Firstly, there’s a mismatch of interests where the seller remains in the business post-sale. The buyer in theory controls the company, but the seller needs some of that control to achieve the KPIs.
Secondly, the parties may manipulate the business post-sale, for example, the seller may drive down costs artificially to boost earnings, or the buyer inflates costs to decrease profits.
One alternative to an earn-out is a staggered purchase. The parties agree a valuation, the seller gets cash and shares on completion. The seller’s remaining shareholding are then sold to the buyer on a staged basis during a set period using put options. These are valued in using an agreed formula and exercisable on a staged basis.
Alternatively, you can use call options. The seller remains on the board of the company and can opt to exercise the options or remain working for the company. Equally, the buyer may choose not to exercise the call options and operate the business jointly with the seller.
For this kind of staggered arrangement to succeed, the seller and the buyer need to work closely together to manage the business post-sale. This way, the purchase price is less susceptible to manipulation by either side.
When an earn-out is based on future earnings, the interests of the buyer and seller are misaligned, post-sale. Should a buyer, for example, lose key customers, sell key assets, or otherwise take decisions that impact earnings, the value of the earn-out for the seller is reduced.
For this reason, the seller is often asked to remain in the business for a certain period to protect the buyer’s interests. Their service contract or employment agreement should contain terms that stop the buyer from interfering with the seller’s ability to meet the KPIs such as artificially reducing the marketing budget or cutting staffing levels. A well-drafted director’s service agreement protects both your business and its leadership. Learn what to include, how it differs from employment contracts, and why it’s crucial for legal clarity and accountability.
Equally, if the seller is not going to stay on, the sale and purchase agreement should provide that the buyer can’t do anything that impacts revenue or profitability. The buyer might be asked to run the business in the same way as it operated pre-sale to maximise the chance of the earn-out target being achieved.
Our earn-out solicitors specialise in mergers and acquisitions (M&A) for start ups and high-growth businesses. Contact us now by filling out the enquiry form below or by phoning 0800 689 1700.
About our expert
Partner - Corporate
Matt is an experienced corporate lawyer who advises businesses, founders, management teams and investors on a broad range of corporate matters. Qualifying in 2012, he helps clients navigate transactions and strategic business decisions with clear, commercially focused advice.
Corporate Governance Lawyers Corporate Law Corporate Restructuring Crowdfunding Legal Services Exits and Disposals Investment Agreements Joint Venture Agreements and 8 more...
28 February
What should a share purchase agreement include?...
8 August
How to evaluate a company for acquisition...
31 July
Roll-up acquisition strategy: what is a roll-up?...
26 July
FAQs: dealing with mergers and acquisitions...
19 July