Knowledge Hub
for Growth


Workplace investigations – An introductory guide for employers and HR professionals


Article

17 mins read

Updated on 16 October 2026

Our subject expert
Sally Gwilliam

Partner - Employment Law

A flawed workplace investigation can turn a manageable issue into a tribunal loss, and unfair dismissal awards escalate quickly when employers skip the clear steps set out in the Acas Code of Practice.

Workplace investigations can be an emotive and time sensitive part of an HR professional’s workload. From collecting evidence to meeting witnesses, conducting investigations requires both meticulous attention to detail and a thoughtful, empathetic approach. In this guide, we take you through all the essentials to help you plan and carry out a thorough and efficient investigation, together with some tips on best practices.

Need an independent hand? Speak to our employment law solicitors about conducting or reviewing your investigation and keep the process watertight from day one.

Contents:

  1. What are workplace investigations and why are they important?
  2. When might you need to carry out a workplace investigation?
  3. Is a workplace investigation always needed?
  4. How do you carry out a workplace investigation?
  5. Who should carry out a workplace investigation?
  6. Who should you interview as part of a workplace investigation and in what order?
  7. What happens at a workplace investigation meeting and how should you set them up?
  8. How should you report your workplace investigation findings?
  9. What should happen after the workplace investigation?
  10. Summary

What are workplace investigations and why are they important?

In the HR context, a workplace investigation is an internal review of specific incidents, allegations or concerns within an organisation. They usually involve a member of HR or a senior manager meeting witnesses and gathering evidence with a view to preparing an investigation report. In essence, investigations are all about establishing the facts of a matter in a way that’s impartial and ultimately leads to some sort of resolution to whatever has happened.

Investigations are important because they help you manage and resolve sensitive workplace issues such as misconduct, grievances, harassment, and whistleblowing. Investigations also help you reduce the risk of legal claims under employment law. For example, a reasonable investigation can help you show an employment tribunal that you adopted a fair process before dismissing an employee.

In disciplinary and grievance cases, investigations also help you comply with the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures ('ACAS Code'). An unreasonable failure to follow the ACAS Code can lead to adverse consequences in employment tribunals, including an increase of up to 25% in compensation.

When might you need to carry out a workplace investigation?

There are many situations in the workplace that require investigations. These include:

Is a workplace investigation always needed?

Investigations can be labour and time intensive for HR teams and senior management. They also represent a significant escalation of a workplace issue that may inflame employee relations and harm team morale. It’s important to assess each situation carefully to determine if a formal investigation is necessary and whether there are alternative ways to resolve the matter.

For most disciplinary and grievance matters, the ACAS Code expects you to be able to address them informally and to explore mediation where possible. This is likely to be appropriate for less sensitive workplace matters that can be resolved through informal communication between employees and their line managers. This might include, for example, complaints and issues about simple payroll mistakes, an employee’s workload and working relationships within teams. Launching a full scale investigation in these circumstances may be disproportionate when an informal conversation might be all that’s needed.

There are many situations where an informal approach is not recommended. These include allegations of serious workplace misconduct (eg theft, fraud, violence), all forms of bullying and harassment (including sexual harassment) and whistleblowing disclosures. In these cases, it’s best to try to proceed to a more formal process as quickly as possible.

How do you carry out a workplace investigation?

How you conduct an investigation depends on the type of investigation needed (eg disciplinary, grievance or whistleblowing) and what your internal policies and procedures say. General guidance is provided for all investigations below, but we encourage you to speak to one of our employment law solicitors for advice on your specific investigation as additional requirements may apply in certain contexts (eg. FCA regulated firms):

Who should carry out a workplace investigation?

You should check what any of your internal policies say about who should conduct the investigation. If your policies don’t specify who should act as the investigator, then ideally you should appoint someone within your business who is independent from the matters that are the subject of the investigation and with appropriate experience and training in carrying out investigations.

In most cases, investigators are senior members of HR, but can also be senior managers from other business units if the investigation relates to a specific function (eg finance). Although you will want to find someone sufficiently senior within your business to carry out the investigation, you may still need other appropriately senior staff later down the line to hear appeals or to act as a disciplinary hearing chairperson. For that reason, try not to appoint the most senior person within your business at the investigation stage.

You might also like to think about the specific characteristics of the investigator that could be helpful. In sexual harassment complaints, a female accuser may be more comfortable speaking to a female investigator than a male investigator. In discrimination complaints, it would be helpful for the investigator to have experience and training in diversity, equity and inclusion topics where possible.

There may be some cases where an external investigator is needed. It could be that your business does not have anyone with the necessary HR or investigation skills needed to carry out an investigation, or the subject matter of the investigation is exceptionally serious or sensitive and an independent external investigator is deemed more appropriate. Our employment solicitors are regularly instructed to act as independent external investigators so they have a wealth of experience in conducting an investigation. If you find yourself needing such support, then speak to one of our employment law solicitors.

Who should you interview as part of a workplace investigation and in what order?

You should arrange investigation meetings with all key employees involved in the subject matter of the investigation. In grievances and whistleblowing disclosures, this will involve meeting the employee making the complaint or disclosure and any other employees that have allegations made against them. In disciplinary cases, this would involve meeting the employee who is accused of misconduct and any witnesses to the misconduct. You should ideally meet the person making the complaint or disclosure first to record their version of events. You should then meet any witnesses that are relevant to the matter afterwards.

When thinking about who to interview as part of your investigation, you should balance the need to collect all relevant evidence against the need to try to contain the investigation as far as possible. It is not necessary to interview every potential witness if this will result in confidentiality breaking down or the scope of the investigation expanding significantly. Instead, focus on key witnesses and if their accounts are similar, that should be enough. At the same time, if new information comes to light during an investigation, you must interview any additional witnesses that could provide useful information. The most important thing is that you interview all obvious witnesses and you don’t leave anyone out that could significantly help the investigation.

What happens at a workplace investigation meeting and how should you set them up?

Investigation meetings are an opportunity for an employee to provide their version of events and for the investigator to establish the facts. They should be neutral and focused on establishing what happened. Importantly for disciplinary investigations, investigation meetings are not the same thing as a disciplinary hearing, meaning the investigator must not make accusations or give the impression that a particular outcome will apply. We suggest the following process for running investigation meetings:

How should you report your workplace investigation findings?

After completing the investigation, the investigator should report their findings in a well structured investigation report. The report should include an introduction providing the background of the investigation, a summary of the investigation process and witnesses, which facts were established and which were not, and a conclusion with any recommendations for further action. Witness statements and evidence gathered as part of the investigation are usually attached to the investigation report.

One question clients often ask is how detailed the investigation report should be. Generally, the length and detail of a report should be proportionate to the complexity of the matter – ie an investigation into serious allegations of financial irregularity is likely to justify a very extensive and technical report compared to a straightforward grievance about an employee’s working hours. What’s most important is that the report establishes all of the relevant facts and is a neutral reflection of the investigator’s independent conclusions.

What should happen after the workplace investigation?

After concluding the investigation and writing up the investigation report, there are still a number of steps that need to be completed before you can close down the investigation in full:

Summary

A fair and well planned workplace investigation can help employers establish the facts, manage employee relations issues appropriately and reduce legal risk. The process should be proportionate, impartial and consistent with your internal policies and the ACAS Code where applicable.

Particular care should be taken around confidentiality, witness evidence, record keeping, employee wellbeing and any subsequent disciplinary or grievance process.

Our employment law solicitors are on hand to advise on all aspects of workplace investigations and can provide training on best practices.

About our expert

Sally Gwilliam

Partner - Employment Law

Sally is a partner in Harper James’ employment teams who helps businesses manage workplace issues, resolve disputes and reduce employment risk.

View Profile 


Areas of Expertise

Absence & Sickness Management Dealing With Discrimination For Employers Defending Employment Tribunal claims Discipline & Grievance Procedures Employment Contracts Employment Law Employment Status and IR35 and 7 more...

Recent content

28 January

The Employment Rights Act: a roadmap for employers... 

21 November

Bereavement leave and pregnancy loss consultation... 

23 July

Employment Rights Act: changes to family-related r... 

17 June

Employment Rights Bill: Day One Rights... 

10 April

Neurodiversity at work – legal compliance for em... 