Knowledge Hub
for Growth


Best practices for payment service providers in the fight against money mules


Article

7 mins read

Updated on 5 December 2023

Our subject expert
John Pauley

Partner - Financial Services

Fraud made up over 40% of UK crime in 2022. Preventing the laundering of criminal proceeds continues to be a key challenge in the fight against fraudsters.

Payment service providers and e-money institutions have legal and regulatory obligations to play their part in combatting financial crime. This includes taking steps to disrupt money laundering operations, including networks of ‘money mules’, or people who, knowingly or unwittingly, use their payment accounts to transfer criminal proceeds.

In October 2023, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) published the findings of a multi-firm review into the systems and controls which payment service providers and e-money firms have in place to combat money mules. Here, we summarise the key ‘best practice’ takeaways from the FCA review.

If you need help and support in reviewing your business’ financial crime compliance processes or putting in place enhanced measures to tackle money mules, our financial services solicitors are here to support you.

Contents:

  1. My business offers payment services or e-money. Why is the FCA ‘money mule’ review relevant to me?
  2. Why is the FCA focusing on combatting ‘money mules’?
  3. What examples of good practice in tackling money mules did the FCA find at payment and e-money firms which I could replicate in my own business?
  4. What areas of weakness did the FCA find? Could these also be a problem for my firm?
  5. Conclusion

My business offers payment services or e-money. Why is the FCA ‘money mule’ review relevant to me?

If your business is offering payment services or e-money, you should ensure your firm is meeting your legal obligations, and the standards which the FCA expects, in preventing financial crime.

Best practice in preventing financial crimes includes taking onboard the findings of the recent FCA multi-firm review into combatting money mules. The FCA makes it clear that they will use their full regulatory toolkit, including enforcement action, in cases where firms fail to maintain proportionate controls to combat money mules.

More information about regulatory expectations for payment services and e-money firms in tackling risk of financial crime can be found in Chapter 19 of the FCA’s ‘Approach to Payment Services and Electronic Money’ document.  Further relevant FCA guidance on combatting financial crime is found in the Financial Crime Guide (FCG) and Financial Crime Thematic Reviews (FCTR) regulatory guides.

For further advice and support on meeting regulatory standards for combatting financial crime in your payments or e-money business, please do not hesitate to contact Harper James’ financial services solicitors.

Why is the FCA focusing on combatting ‘money mules’?

Fraudsters seek to ‘launder’ criminal proceeds through multiple accounts and financial firms to try to obscure the origins of their money. Profits can then be converted into cash or cryptocurrencies which appear to come from legitimate sources.

To do this, fraudsters seek to use networks of ‘money mule’ accounts to transfer funds around the financial system. In 2022, firms reported to the National Fraud Database more than 39,000 accounts which they believed could be linked to mule activity. These issues put at risk confidence in the integrity of the UK financial system.

The FCA also has concerns about harm to consumers. Especially with the cost-of-living crisis, people may be persuaded to operate mule accounts, attracted by easy money or deceived by seemingly convincing cover stories such as ‘work at home for cash’ jobs. Being involved in a money mule scheme can have serious detrimental effects for consumers, including criminal charges, damage to credit ratings, exclusion from financial services or being threatened by the criminal fraternity.

What examples of good practice in tackling money mules did the FCA find at payment and e-money firms which I could replicate in my own business?

The FCA found that many payment and e-money firms have in place effective controls to try to combat ‘money mule’ accounts.

Good practice examples which you could consider replicating for your own business include:

What areas of weakness did the FCA find? Could these also be a problem for my firm?

Despite many examples of good practice, the FCA also highlights important areas where improvements still need to be made.

You should review the systems and controls for combatting money mules in your payment services or e-money business and, if you identify similar issues, take action to remedy any weaknesses in ways which are proportionate to:

Examples of issues which the FCA found include:

Conclusion

In its review, the FCA emphasises the legal and regulatory responsibilities of payment services and e-money firms for tackling financial crime and the possibility of supervisory or enforcement action against firms which fail to meet their obligations.

The FCA expects payment services and e-money firms to consider their own organisation’s arrangements, systems and controls against the findings of the FCA’s money mule multi-firm review. Crucially, firms must consistently:

If you need help and support in reviewing your business’ financial crime compliance processes or putting in place enhanced measures to tackle money mules, our financial services solicitors are here to support you. Our legal experts have experience in advising on the identification and remediation of weaknesses in anti-fraud systems and on how firms can maintain proportionate and adequate controls to prevent its services and customers being exploited by fraudsters. Please get in touch to find out more.

About our expert

John Pauley

Partner - Financial Services

John is a specialist financial services regulatory solicitor who advises fintechs, payment service providers, e-money institutions, consumer credit firms, merchants and many more on navigating complex UK financial regulation.

View Profile 


Areas of Expertise

Banking and Finance Consumer Credit & Hire FCA authorisation Financial Services Regulation Payment Services Lawyers Regulated Banking & Finance Activities

Recent content

21 May

Marketing crypto assets to UK consumers: what you ... 

21 February

Navigating Account Information Services... 

20 February

Buy now pay later: Impact of proposed regulation o... 

28 November

Agents and distributors in the e-money and payment... 

11 November

FCA authorisation FAQs... 