Ask the expert
5 mins read
Updated on 13 April 2022
Our subject expert
Gemma Palmer
Associate Solicitor - Intellectual Property
When a letter lands on your desk accusing your business - and perhaps you personally - of infringing someone's design then no matter how long you have been in business, it's likely to come as a shock. You might be dealing with a misconceived complaint or have made a genuine mistake, our intellectual property solicitors help protect you in this this difficult situation.
At this point, you may also be weighing up whether to reduce risk by stopping selling, offering for sale, or importing the allegedly infringing product or stop using the allegedly infringing process – if this is possible. If you are considering this route, our corporate, commercial and civil litigation colleagues will support the IP team in advising whether this could impact on your existing contractual obligations.
Once you share the letter with our team of IP solicitors, we will triage the situation – calculating if there is a real risk of imminent litigation and if so in what jurisdiction, for what cause and with what consequences. Armed with this information, our team of solicitors will build a personalised strategy.
The components of a good strategy include:
Together we will work jointly to answer a series of questions – some you will answer, some we will:
The Accuser:
The Complaint:
You:
In most registered design cases, a counter-attack of some form is mounted to revoke or invalidate the registered design relied on, or to contest its ownership
Most registered designs are members of families extending beyond the UK – any of them might be liable to attack through procedures within the design office where they are proceeding such as observations, opposition, or revocation actions.
If UK proceedings are issued, the majority of defences are accompanied by a counterclaim asking the court to invalidate the registered design relied on (rendering it null and void).
Invalidity counterclaims usually invite the court to find that the registered design should not have been registered as the design was not a true invention, either because it lacked novelty or because it is too like previous registered or unregistered designs.
Remember, to identify the best strategy, you and our design solicitors must exchange information until you establish what this inbound accusation means for the business and whether you have the finances to mount an outbound counterclaim. Potentially, you consider bringing in civil litigators to support us on any contract or misrepresentation claim that you may be able to bargain with.
If the allegation relates to an unregistered design, that means your opponent needs to prove that it qualifies for legal protection – they will not have the benefit of any certificate to demonstrate this. It may turn out that the alleged design does not qualify, has expired, or that the complainant is not its true owner.
Our next steps will take into account the many similar cases we have seen before. Sometimes the most sophisticated strategy results in a short letter – sometimes you won’t even tell your accuser that you are represented. Sometimes attack is the best form of defence. Sometimes a show of respect is required to smooth troubled waters. What we can promise is that the strategy will be tailored to you.
In the limited number of design cases that go to court, accusers need to show that:
Paying damages usually wouldn’t be dealt with by a court until all the questions above had been dealt with – usually at a second trial. Typically, the legal costs of taking a claim to trial is often larger than the eventual theoretical damages awarded, Our low cost model can help keep legal costs to a minimum.
To find out more about designs, or to learn more about registered designs read our article FAQs: registered design rights. Alternatively, if you would like to register your design read our guide to registering a design.
Associate Solicitor - Intellectual Property
Having originally joined us in 2016 as a legal assistant, Gemma trained as a solicitor with Harper James and qualified as an intellectual property solicitor in 2021. Gemma has a strong corporate background which enables her to see the bigger picture of a business and informs her strategic advice.
Copyright Lawyers Design Rights Intellectual Property Intellectual Property Audits Intellectual Property Disputes Intellectual Property Licensing Intellectual Property Strategy and 4 more...
28 December
Design invalidity: clearing the way for your produ...
Ask the expert
28 July 2026
Ask the expert
23 April 2026
Ask the expert
30 January 2026
Ask the expert
13 January 2026
Ask the expert
7 November 2025
To access legal support from just £174 per hour arrange your no-obligation consultation today. We aim to respond to all messages received within 24 hours.