Thoughts and opinions

2 mins read

Updated on 14 February 2024

Could the MoD’s recent ICO fine happen to your business?

Our subject expert
Becky White

Senior Solicitor - Data Protection & Privacy

The Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) recently fined the Ministry of Defence (MoD) £350 000 for disclosing personal information of over 200 Afghan nationals, who were eligible for evacuation from Afghanistan and seeking relocation to the UK. The incident occurred in September 2021 when the MOD mistakenly used the 'To' field in an email, rather than putting recipients on blind copy, inadvertently disclosing the email addresses of all 245 recipients. 

Among the recipients, 55 had visible thumbnail pictures on their email profiles, two individuals 'replied to all' potentially without realising it, and one person inadvertently disclosed their location. The personal data breach compromised the identity and safety of the affected individuals, who were already in a vulnerable situation, putting them at risk of serious harm if the information had fallen into the hands of the Taliban. The information commissioner, John Edwards, said the error 'let down those to whom our country owes so much'.

In response to this breach, the MoD conducted an internal investigation, made a statement in parliament, and updated their email policies and processes including implementing a policy in which an email initiated by one staff member is cross-checked by another to prevent such errors in the future.

This personal data breach is an extreme example of the significant risks that can arise when basic data protection fails due to human error. Indeed, over the past three years, from 2021 to 2023, the ICO’s Data Security Incident Trends report found that incorrectly addressed emails were the incidents most frequently reported. Failure to use blind copy when appropriate, as exemplified in this MoD case, is also an ongoing issue.

Organisations can prevent these types of basic personal data breaches by implementing proper policies and processes, particularly when sending bulk emails, and encouraging their staff to follow good email practices. Those handling sensitive personal data should prioritise integrating these foundational data security practices.

Our data protection expert Becky White provided the following perspective:

The potentially fatal consequences of this particular data breach highlight the vital importance of implementing appropriate data handling protocols, especially in terms of bulk emailing. Additionally, conducting regular staff training is critical to ensure staff understand security risks and instinctively follow correct procedures.

With so much of our lives now online and accessible, the risk of information falling into the wrong hands is increasing.  The MoD incident drives home the importance of keeping personal data secure and should serve as a wakeup call to any organisation that does not take data protection seriously.

For smaller organisations, meeting training and compliance obligations can be difficult. Our data protection package delivers the essentials like staff training materials, audits and advice tailored to your needs and resources.

About our expert

Becky White

Senior Solicitor - Data Protection & Privacy

Becky is a highly experienced data protection solicitor who qualified in 2002. She helps growth-focused businesses navigate data protection law with confidence, turning compliance from a burden into a genuine competitive advantage. Becky understands both the legal requirements and the real-world pressures her clients face, building privacy compliance programmes that are commercially fit for purpose.

View Profile 


Areas of Expertise

Commercial Contracts Data Breaches & Incident Management Data Governance Data Processing Agreements Data Protection & Privacy Law Data Protection Health Check Data Protection Impact Assessments and 10 more...

Recent content

21 May

How to create a data protection complaints process... 

17 June

What is a data processing agreement?... 

17 June

Your guide to data sharing agreements... 

16 June

Data protection compliance and monitoring staff... 

16 June

Data protection in HR: key risks and priorities fo... 

Thoughts and opinions

28 October 2026

When AI gets it wrong: Could a mistake made by AI result in a business dispute? 

Thoughts and opinions

13 October 2026

What the latest cyber incidents tell SMEs about third-party risk 

Thoughts and opinions

21 September 2026

When a bigger brand challenges your trade mark: lessons from Airbnb and bnb-side 

Thoughts and opinions

10 September 2026

Corporate reporting reform: what could it mean for growing businesses?

Thoughts and opinions

21 August 2026

The Anthropic settlement and the risks of a “use first, pay later” approach to AI and...

How can we help?

To access legal support from just £174 per hour arrange your no-obligation consultation today. We aim to respond to all messages received within 24 hours.

Make an enquiry