Article
16 mins read
Updated on 25 July 2025
Our subject expert
Ian Carson
Partner and Head of Dispute Resolution
As a shareholder of a company, it’s important to know that in certain circumstances, the law gives you the right to ‘remedies’ (legal actions you can take as a shareholder) if you are in shareholder dispute with the company and its directors, or if you think that your rights as a member are being compromised. We’ve put together this article to set out what those shareholder remedies are, when they are available and what you as a shareholder have to do to be able to use them.
If you are reading this article because you are in a dispute and you are looking for practical advice, we can help. Our shareholder dispute solicitors have decades of experience helping shareholders like you resolve a dispute. If you instruct us we will be committed to fighting your corner and will do everything we can to protect you and your rights as a shareholder.
Under statutory law, there are three main remedies available to you as a shareholder of a company if you think that your rights as a member have been compromised:
These remedies are important for a member to have, particularly if you don’t hold a large number of shares in the company you’ve invested in and are in the minority when it comes to making decisions about the company as a whole.
A word of warning, each of the three processes relies heavily on the wide discretion of the court, and each one is complex and likely to be costly to pursue. If you’re looking to start the process of any shareholder remedy, we recommend seeking legal advice. Our experienced business dispute solicitors are well equipped to support and guide you throughout.
This remedy is quite literally a show-stopper. If you believe that it would be just and equitable for a company to be put into liquidation and cease to do business (widely referred to as the ‘winding up’ of the company), you can make a petition to the English courts under the Insolvency Act 1986. If you’re considering making a petition, it’s a good idea to seek legal guidance on how to do so, as the petition process is complex and needs to be closely followed.
In England and Wales, a petition can be brought in relation to a company that has been incorporated under the Companies Act 1985 or the Companies Act 2006 and in certain circumstances, foreign companies that carry out their business in England or Wales.
What the court considers to be ‘just and equitable’ is not set in stone. A winding up process like this is a discretionary remedy, meaning that the court can decide how it would like to act depending on the facts and circumstances of the individual case. The most common reasons that the court will consider the winding up of a company to be just and reasonable are:
Even though petitions can be made by people that are not necessarily shareholders of the company (such as directors of the company – for themselves or on behalf of the company itself, and creditors), the fact that the grounds for the petition need to be just and equitable (and are usually connected to the strategy and management of the company) means that it is common for the person making the petition to the courts to be a shareholder of the company at the time that the petition is being made.
For a petition to be eligible for court review, the number of shareholders of the company must have been reduced below two or at least some of the shares of the company held by the petitioning member have to have been originally either given to or held by that member (and registered in their name) for at least six months during the 18 months before the start of the winding up process. Another option is that the petitioning shareholder has ended up with the shares through the death of a former shareholder.
As well as these requirements, English case law has set out that a shareholder must have a tangible interest in what is leftover in the company after the company has gone into liquidation. This means that it is likely that there will be some value left in the company for the petitioning member once the company has gone through the liquidation (including any insolvency) processes. If there is no value left, the petition will not be successful.
Another barrier to success is that if the court hearing the petition thinks that there is another route or remedy available to the petitioning person, it’s likely that the court will not make a winding up order if it thinks it is unreasonable to ask for the winding up of the company rather than trying to claim the other remedy. The seriousness of the just and equitable grounds will also be taken into account.
As this remedy has a finality to it and can have chaotic consequences, where a company is being wound up voluntarily in England and Wales, the court will not usually make a winding up order as a result of a member’s petition unless it is convinced that the voluntary winding up does not take into account the interests of the creditors or shareholders of the company being wound up.
Ultimately, this remedy is one that relies on the opinion of the court, its interpretation of the facts and circumstances at the time of the petition and the availability of other, less potentially draconian remedies that the petitioning party may have access to, after all, the winding up of a company can have a major impact on a lot of other parties.
So, what constitutes ‘unfair prejudice’? Ultimately, this will be down to the court to decide, but English case law has suggested that for unfair prejudice to take place, something has to have happened or not happened (either committed in the past, happening now or that might happen in the future) that relates to the way in which the company’s business and affairs are handled and that must have unfairly disadvantaged certain people. Case law suggests that what counts as ‘unfairness’ should be judged by that word’s ordinary meaning: a lack of equality or justice, which practically on a day-to-day level of management might involve not keeping promises or honouring agreements.
Both ‘unfairness’ and ‘prejudice’ need to be individually assessed. Case law also suggests that the prejudice that the petitioning person has suffered has to be substantial. This can either be:
To be clear, if you’re acting in the capacity of a petitioning party, you have to actually be able to show that you have lost out as a result of the unfair prejudice.
Examples of unfair prejudice include:
A petitioning shareholder might not be able to make a successful petition if they hold enough shares or power in the company’s decision-making which means that they could easily rectify the situation by voting a certain way, or otherwise doing something that would change the unfair outcome or situation.
The court’s discretion to make any order to remedy what it considers to be the unfair prejudice in question means that it has a number of options available to it, including:
As you have probably guessed, this is another remedy where the petition-making process is complicated and getting it right is important, so it’s advisable to seek legal advice before starting the process. Delay in presenting the petition can mean that the court will refuse to hear it, and there may be other contractual remedies available to the petitioning party that are set out in a shareholders’ agreement (or the articles of association of the company) that might give the petitioning member a better outcome.
Under the Companies Act 2006, members of a company, trustees or personal representatives holding shares in the company can bring a claim against a director on behalf of that company because of something that the director did or proposed to do (or didn’t/proposed not to do) which was negligent, in default, in breach of their duties, or in breach of trust in respect of their actions and responsibilities towards the company. This is called a ‘derivative claim’. In some circumstances, a shareholder can even take over a derivative claim that was started by the company itself.
A derivative claim can also be brought against a former director of the company or a shadow director of the company (a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors of a company are accustomed to act).
The Companies Act 2006 sets out the two-stage procedure that members need to follow to bring a derivative claim. At the first stage, the petitioning party will need the court’s permission to progress with the claim, so the court can judge (exercising its own discretion) whether or not the claim has met all of the pre-conditions that it needs to, in order to continue along the statutory process and to be taken seriously.
When the court is deciding whether to continue with a claim, it has to consider all relevant matters (including several factors set out in the Companies Act 2006), such as:
The two pre-conditions are:
The court can then grant full, limited or conditional permission to carry on the claim to the second stage of the process: the court hearing of the claim.
As we’ve touched on earlier, this is a complex process and getting professional legal assistance to make and submit the claim is advised. It can be confusing when considering whether to bring a derivative claim or to make an unfair prejudice petition because a breach of a director’s duty that causes an unfair prejudice toward a shareholder can fall into both types of relief.
In fact, due to its complicated two-stage process, the statutory derivative claim is not a favoured remedy because even though it was introduced to make the claim process more flexible for minority shareholders, the wide discretion that the courts have to interpret the process means that you cannot be sure of the outcome when you start the two-stage process. Plus, there is the likelihood that you will incur significant costs with no guarantee of being indemnified by the company for them (i.e., there’s no guarantee that the company will pay the petitioning member’s costs on its behalf).
For a deeper dive, please read our dedicated guides on derivative claims and winding up petitions.
Directors only owe their duties to the company, and so shareholder remedies have to be made indirectly against directors. One way of doing this is by bringing a derivative claim on behalf of the company.
Another way is to remove the director from their position on the board of the company. Under the Companies Act 2006, shareholders can remove a director by making a decision, called an ordinary resolution, where more than 50% of the shareholders that are entitled to vote on the decision approve the decision. If this were to happen, be aware that if the director is employed by the company, their employment may continue if the term of the director’s service contract is not linked to their term as a statutory director.
In certain circumstances where the director has acted against these duties (for example, by committing fraud, persistently breaching the legislation provided for by the Companies Acts, or on conviction of an indictable offence), a court can make a disqualification order against a person to stop them becoming or remaining a director for a period of up to 15 years.
It’s worth noting that there are a few ways in which a director may be protected from liabilities arising as a result of their acts as a director. The articles of association of a company will usually contain a limit of liability and/or an indemnity for directors acting on its behalf. If it appears to the court that a director is or may be liable but, considering the circumstances of the case, it looks like they acted honestly and reasonably, the court can relieve the director (either wholly or partially), from liability.
There is not much variance in the main shareholder remedies between public and private companies in England and Wales. A lot will depend on how the individual company has chosen to be governed. Companies can set out certain rules in their articles of association and shareholders’ agreements that will affect shareholders, such as rules that shares cannot be sold without first offering them to existing shareholders, and information sharing rules and notice period requirements for meetings.
If a company has different sets of shares (called classes of shares), different shareholders can have different rights depending on what has been agreed between those shareholders and the company. These classes of shares will usually be set out in the company’s articles of association. In some cases, the company may give certain shares more votes than others and this again can be a remedy for shareholders (although in reality, this is likely to be a right for majority shareholders and may put minority shareholders in a worse position).
It’s more likely that private companies will have better shareholder protections, and often companies with a shareholders’ agreement will set out in detail the ways in which shareholders can veto, modify or waive certain courses of action of the company. They may also specify in more detail than the articles what consultation or information rights a shareholder has. (These are just some of the many reasons why it’s advisable to have a shareholders’ agreement in place.)
As well as the statutory remedies of just and equitable winding up, unfair prejudice petitions and the derivative claim, the Companies Act 2006 gives minority shareholders certain protections as part of the general governance of the company. To what extent a minority shareholder can benefit from those protections will depend on how many shares that shareholder holds and the voting rights attached to those shares (which makes sense: if a shareholder holds 1%, it should not be able to overrule the strategy of a company where other shareholders hold 99% of the shares).
In summary:
As well as the above remedies, the minority shareholder can sometimes also rely on a negotiated position in the company’s shareholders’ agreement or articles of association, where, if able, it can incorporate provisions that provide it with remedies, including:
Yes, the Companies Act 2006 states that the articles of association of a company are a contract between the shareholders and the company. On this basis, a shareholder can claim against the company if their rights as a member are breached or infringed – see the section on unfair prejudice petitions. A breach of the obligations of the articles of association will also usually make the action taken void or invalid.
As mentioned earlier when highlighting the benefits of having a shareholders’ agreement in place, it’s sensible to think about putting one together because the articles of association are public documents – whereas a shareholders’ agreement is a private contract between the shareholders and the company (and so may contain more provisions that protect shareholders). A breach of these provisions may mean a shareholder might be entitled to more remedies, such as damages or an injunction.
If you’re a shareholder facing difficulties, there are several legal routes you can take to protect your interests. These include petitions for just and equitable winding up, claims for unfair prejudice, and derivative actions against directors. While these tools offer important protections, they can be complex and costly, with no guaranteed outcomes. Often, the best way to avoid disputes is through well-drafted shareholders’ agreements and company articles. If you find yourself in a shareholder dispute, getting prompt legal advice from our business dispute solicitors is key to understanding your options and protecting your position.
About our expert
Partner and Head of Dispute Resolution
Ian is a Partner and Head of Dispute Resolution at Harper James. He qualified as a solicitor in 1993 and has over 30 years of experience in handling a broad range of commercial disputes.
Alternative Dispute Resolution Breach of Contract Solicitors Business Disputes Commercial Contract Disputes Commercial Litigation Commercial debt recovery Construction & Engineering Disputes and 5 more...
30 September
Dividend disputes and the non-payment of dividends...
11 June
What is misrepresentation in a contract?...
21 May
Misappropriation of company funds...
14 May
GC focus: Dispute resolution priorities...
10 March