Knowledge Hub
for Growth


Guarantees in commercial leases


Article

10 mins read

Updated on 1 June 2022

Our subject expert
Abdi Ebrahimi

Partner - Commercial Property Development

Guarantees in commercial leases are a common, but often misunderstood, part of lease negotiations. If you're taking on a lease or acting as a guarantor, it's vital to understand the legal and financial obligations that come with it. Getting it wrong can leave you or your business exposed to unexpected liabilities.

This article is for business owners, property managers, and anyone entering into a commercial lease arrangement. You'll learn when guarantees are required, how they work, and the risks involved for both tenants and guarantors. By the end, you’ll have a clearer picture of your responsibilities and how to protect your position in lease negotiations.

If you're reviewing a commercial lease or have concerns about a personal guarantee, our experienced commercial property solicitors can help. We’ll guide you through your options and ensure you fully understand your legal obligations before you sign on the dotted line.

Jump to:

  1. What is a guarantee?
  2. When can a landlord require a guarantee to be given?
  3. How are guarantees used?
  4. Who can be a guarantor for a commercial lease?
  5. Guaranteeing a commercial lease as an individual
  6. What happens if a guarantor cannot pay rent?
  7. What are the limits on a guarantee?
  8. Alternatives to guarantees

What is a guarantee?

A guarantee is a promise given by one party ('the guarantor') that another party will meet its obligations. If the other party fails to meet its obligations, then the guarantor can be asked to meet the shortfall (if the payment of money is involved) or pay for the default to be rectified (or in the worst case be sued for damages).  In some cases, the guarantor may have to step into the shoes of the other party if, for example, it ceases to exist.

When can a landlord require a guarantee to be given?

In lease transactions guarantees play a particularly important role by providing landlords with more confidence that the tenant will comply with its obligations under the lease.

Given that a tenant often commits to significant liabilities under a commercial lease (including, among others, the payment of rent and  keeping the property in repair) but at the same time either has limited financial resources or is a limited company with few assets of its own (described as having 'poor covenant strength') a landlord will often be reluctant to grant a lease unless the tenant can provide some sort of guarantee. A guarantee provides the landlord with a form of security that the Landlord can turn to if the tenant defaults.

An effective guarantee will allow the landlord to recover monies from the guarantor and/or insist that the guarantor fulfils the tenant’s obligations. 

A landlord can ask for a guarantee to be given in two particular cases:

  1. When the landlord grants a new lease;
  2. When an existing tenant needs to ask its landlord for permission to transfer its lease to a new tenant (known as “assigning the lease”).

Whether in either of these circumstances, the landlord can insist on the guarantee being given depends on all the surrounding circumstances. It is not unusual for a landlord to ask for a guarantee to be given even though it is unreasonable (and even unlawful) for them to do so.  If you are a tenant, you should take advice before agreeing to give a guarantee just because the landlord demands it.

On an assignment, in addition to this type of third party guarantee, the lease may contain an obligation on the tenant to provide an authorised guarantee agreement (AGA) from the outgoing tenant that the new tenant will fulfil its obligations under the lease if the lease.  The terms of the lease will govern when an AGA must be given so should be considered at the time the lease is granted.  An AGA is different to a third-party guarantee because it simply requires that the outgoing tenant remains responsible for its obligations under the lease if the new tenant defaults but only (usually) until the new tenant itself assigns the lease to someone else.  A landlord may require both a third-party guarantee and an AGA to be given. 

For more information on the process of transferring a lease, read our guide: Assigning a commercial property lease to another business

How are guarantees used?

A landlord will usually seek to enforce the lease terms against the actual tenant.  It is only if the tenant defaults that it will seek to enforce the obligation against the guarantor.

Depending on how the lease and guarantee are drafted, it is not ordinarily necessary for the landlord to be required to serve any form of ‘formal’ demand on the guarantor (the situation is slightly different in the cases of AGAs but that is outside the scope of this guide). As long as a demand has been made on the tenant if required pursuant to the terms of the lease (which creates the principal liability) the guarantor will be liable without the need for any further notice. In practice of course, if the tenant does default, the landlord will contact the guarantor and demand payment but this does not create the liability. The guarantor is just being notified of a liability that has already arisen.

Because the guarantor only has a secondary liability, if for any reason the tenant ceases to be liable to the landlord (e.g. because the landlord has forfeited the lease and brought it to an end) the guarantor will usually no longer be liable.  A guarantee will therefore usually permit the landlord to require the guarantor to take a new lease (instead of the tenant) or make a payment to the landlord to meet the liabilities under the lease.

Who can be a guarantor for a commercial lease?

Any individual or any company with capacity can be a guarantor for a commercial lease. The term ‘with capacity’ is important. For example, if a company is giving a guarantee it should have specific powers to do so under its memorandum or articles of association the directors of a company giving a guarantee should be able to show that they are acting within their power in order to promote the success of the guarantor company as well as the tenant and that it has been properly approved under the company’s constitution.

A landlord should be cautious about who they accept as guarantors and of statutory protections offered to guarantors. This includes risks that some of the terms of the guarantee could be deemed ‘unfair’ and therefore not enforceable. Circumstances where a guarantee may not be enforceable include:

To avoid these difficulties guarantees should be drafted and entered into with care and often it is sensible for the landlord to require the guarantor to obtain independent legal advice on the terms of the guarantee so that the guarantor cannot claim that it was forced into signing something it did not understand. Our commercial property solicitors will be happy to advise.

Guaranteeing a commercial lease as an individual

If a guarantor is an individual, then they will take on personal liability for the obligations under the lease if the guarantee is called upon. A landlord will wish to ensure that the individual is of sufficient financial standing to meet its liabilities. A third-party guarantee can provide security in such circumstances.

As an individual does not have the limited liability that a limited liability company has, this means that when entering into a guarantee, that all of his or her personal assets are at risk in the event of the tenant defaulting. From the perspective of all the parties therefore, whether obtaining a guarantee from an individual is desirable depends on the financial standing of the proposed guarantor. An individual may be more inclined to ensure that the demands under the lease and the guarantee are met, in order to avoid losing their personal assets. On the other hand, if the individual is of limited means and can no more meet the obligations under the lease than the tenant, such a guarantor is of little benefit to the landlord.

What happens if a guarantor cannot pay rent?

If a tenant has defaulted on its obligations to pay rent and, the landlord having called in the guarantee, finds that the guarantor also fails to pay the rent then the landlord may wish to take the following steps against the guarantor:

If it is clear that none of these steps are likely to result in a payment being made, then the landlord might:

It should be understood that the landlord is not obliged to take any of these steps and its failure to do so does not release the tenant or the guarantor from its obligations.

What are the limits on a guarantee?

A guarantee is a secondary liability which means that it is linked to the principal liability given by the tenant direct to the landlord.  This means that:

Alternatives to guarantees

The tenant should consider offering the following as an alternative to a guarantee:

Whether you're negotiating a new lease or dealing with an existing guarantee, our commercial property solicitors can provide practical, business-focused guidance.

About our expert

Abdi Ebrahimi

Partner - Commercial Property Development

Abdi is a partner in Harper James' commercial property team. He advises clients on general commercial property matters with a particular interest and specialism in relation to development work. This includes reviewing and advising on heads of terms, carrying out title investigations, reviewing and reporting on the benefit or burden of rights and helping clients to understand and manage the risks associated with the land being bought or sold. Once a site has been acquired, Abdi supports clients with the various section agreement and ancillary documents needed to facilitate the development of the land through to the eventual sale or desired exit strategy. 

View Profile 


Areas of Expertise

Commercial Lease Agreement Review Commercial Lease Solicitors Commercial Property Conveyancing Commercial Property Disputes Commercial Property Solicitors Property Development Solicitors Property Finance Solicitors and 2 more...

Recent content

27 August

GC Focus: Commercial property priorities... 

26 March

Understanding conditional contracts and option agr... 

4 February

Unlocking development potential – identifying th... 

7 January

How to avoid overpaying or misjudging site value: ... 

6 November

What is a Section 106 agreement?... 