Article
9 mins read
Updated on 16 August 2022
Our subject expert
Ella Bond
Senior Solicitor - Employment Law
Settlement agreements can offer a clean break for both employer and employee, avoiding the cost, time and stress of a potential tribunal claim. But reaching a fair and legally sound agreement requires careful negotiation and a clear understanding of your legal obligations.
But how should you approach settlement discussions with employees? We’ll explain when a settlement agreement might be appropriate, how to manage the negotiation process, and what terms you should include to protect your business. You’ll also learn how to handle without prejudice conversations and what legal advice is required on both sides.
If you're planning to offer or negotiate a settlement agreement, our expert employment law solicitors can guide you through the process to make sure it's handled lawfully, sensitively and with your business interests protected.
A settlement agreement is a legally binding contract that can be used on the termination of employment. These agreements are voluntary and used to clarify agreed terms. An employee will typically waive their right to make specified claims to a court or employment tribunal, in exchange for a payment made to the employee.
In order for a settlement agreement to be legally valid and binding, the agreement will need to be in writing, must relate to particular complaint(s) or proceedings; and the employee must have received advice from a relevant independent adviser on the terms of the agreement.
The advisor must be identified in the agreement and have a current contract of insurance or professional indemnity insurance covering the risk of a claim by the employee for loss arising from that advice. Finally, the agreement must state that the statutory conditions regulating the settlement agreement have been satisfied.
As settlement agreements are voluntary, they can be used at any time before or after the end of an employment relationship if both the employer and employee agree. It may be that a settlement agreement is proposed by an employer when an employee has raised a concern or brought a claim. However, an employee can equally suggest a ‘protected conversation’ is held and a settlement agreement entered into.
In some instances, a protected conversation or settlement agreement will not achieve the desired result. For example, details of confidential discussions to end employment can be disclosed in court or Tribunal proceedings where an employee subsequently brings claims relating to discrimination or automatic unfair dismissal such as for whistleblowing, union membership or asserting a statutory right. Similarly, where there has been improper behaviour by the employer, this protection does not apply, including where fraud, undue influence or some other ‘unambiguous impropriety’ has arisen such as perjury or blackmail.
Where a settlement agreement is offered, it does not have to be accepted at all. Or, if both parties wish to reach settlement but have not agreed on the precise terms, it is possible for a process of negotiation to ensue. Whether you are in a good bargaining position depends very much on the circumstances in which you find yourself agreeing to a settlement agreement. If this is in response to a claim or grievance, which you believe may be well founded, you are less likely to be in a good position than if you are just looking to expedite a redundancy process. The length of the employee’s service with you is also likely to determine whether you are in a strong bargaining position or not.
In order to best minimise any damage, it is advisable to obtain early legal advice from a settlement agreement lawyer. The negotiation tactics best employed will depend on what the background issues are and the reasoning for the settlement agreement. An expert with experience of negotiating in a number of different scenarios is invaluable.
Our employment law solicitors can guide you on the best way to present a settlement offer and the best timing for this in the circumstances, to minimise the chances of a negative reaction from your employee. You may feel that offering the minimum your business is required to offer to your employee is the correct approach. However, if you offer a little bit more as a tax-free settlement payment, it can speed up the negotiation process. Beware though, that an employee does not gain momentum while negotiating with you and gradually edge you past what you are prepared to pay.
There are a number of pitfalls employers would be wise to avoid when it comes to negotiating settlement agreements. Below are a few:
If you and your employee have agreed the basic terms upon which any outstanding claims will be settled, an employment solicitor can help to draft up a settlement agreement which will reflect those agreed terms. You will need to give careful thought not only to the amount of money you will pay in settlement but also how and when any payments will be made. Further, any conditions that will be attached to the payment, such as return of company property, providing a handover and that no disciplinary matters are later discovered, amongst other things, should be carefully considered and drafted into the agreement.
As discussed above, this may lead to a straightforward signature and return of the agreement once the employee has received legal advice, or it may result in a negotiation process. You may decide to instruct a solicitor to communicate with your employee or their legal adviser, but if you choose to correspond in respect of a settlement agreement, all correspondence should be marked ‘without prejudice and subject to contract’ until the agreement is completed by all parties.
If you and the employee complete a settlement agreement, it becomes a binding contract and both parties must honour its terms to avoid being in breach of contract. Very few claims are carved out of a settlement agreement as the objective is to settle claims, but you are able to enforce the terms of the settlement agreement. As such if a party breaches the agreement once it has been completed, this could result in a breach of contract claim.
In conclusion, seeking legal advice from a settlement agreement lawyer at an early stage can help protect your business from future claims. An experienced solicitor can help you negotiate some of the finer legal details in a settlement agreement. Our experienced employment law solicitors can also help you draft settlement agreements on your behalf. However, if you choose to deal with the settlement agreement negotiation directly, ensure that you label all correspondence relating to the settlement as ‘without prejudice and subject to agreement’ until the agreement completes.
About our expert
Senior Solicitor - Employment Law
Ella is a highly experienced employment solicitor, who qualified in 2007. She helps businesses manage employment issues with confidence, providing practical and commercially focused advice throughout the employment relationship – from recruitment and day-to-day people management to restructures, senior exits and Employment Tribunal claims.
Absence & Sickness Management Dealing With Discrimination For Employers Defending Employment Tribunal claims Discipline & Grievance Procedures Employment Contracts Employment Law Employment Status and IR35 and 7 more...
1 May
Power cuts and blackouts – practical advice for ...
11 March
Individual Redundancy Consultation Guide...
4 March
A guide to restrictive covenants in employment law...
14 February
Setting up a business that competes with your prev...
2 December